As NFC South threatens another sub-.500 division winner, does NFL playoff structure need makeover? 'It'll take an egregious deal'
Key Points:
- As the 2026 NFL season approaches Week 11, concerns grow over whether the playoff structure fairly includes the best teams, with the NFC South potentially sending a sub-.500 division winner to the playoffs again.
- The current eight-division playoff format, unchanged since 2002, is under scrutiny due to increased disparities amplified by the 17-game schedule and the possible addition of an 18th game.
- Proposals to seed wild-card teams above division winners with worse records have failed to gain traction, as many league executives emphasize the importance of divisional rivalries, strength of schedule, and tradition.
- The NFL faces challenges balancing competitive fairness and fan engagement, with divisional games fostering rivalries and maintaining interest, despite some teams having easier schedules or clinching playoff spots early.
- Future playoff debates are likely tied to schedule changes, especially if an 18th game is added, but significant changes to the playoff format are expected to be slow due to the league's emphasis on tradition and divisional competition.