Column: The arrogance of Newsom's death penalty commutations
AI Image

Column: The arrogance of Newsom's death penalty commutations

Los Angeles Times • • nation

Key Points:

  • California Gov. Gavin Newsom plans to grant clemency to all 548 death row inmates, commuting their sentences to life without parole, but critics argue this move stops short of formally abolishing the death penalty through legislative or voter approval.
  • The death penalty in California is seen as a costly, ineffective system with only 13 executions since 1978 and none since 2006, prompting calls for its repeal on practical grounds rather than moral ones.
  • Legal challenges loom as the state Supreme Court must approve commutations for inmates with prior felonies, potentially creating an unmanageable workload before Newsom leaves office, with his successor Xavier Becerra expected to continue the moratorium but unclear on commutations.
  • Critics contend Newsom bypassed democratic processes and voter input, breaking previous promises to respect voter decisions on capital punishment, unlike former Gov. Pat Brown, who balanced personal opposition with respect for the law and public will.
  • The article suggests that true leadership would involve sponsoring a repeal measure for the death penalty in the Legislature and on the ballot, rather than unilateral executive action.

Trending Business

Trending Technology

Trending Health