Most Popular Halloween Candy, Ranked
Key Points:
- Reese's Peanut Butter Cups remain America's top Halloween candy for the third consecutive year, according to DoorDash's 2025 Halloween order data.
- Chocolate candies dominate the list, with Hershey bars and M&M's following closely behind Reese's.
- Sour candies are gaining popularity, with Airheads, Sour Patch Kids, and Haribo gummies entering the top 10; Haribo has recently surpassed Nerds in orders.
- Nostalgic candies like Circus Peanuts, Lemonheads, Bit-O-Honey, candy corn, and raisins have seen significant increases in orders, indicating a resurgence of old-school treats.
- Reese's led candy preferences in 17 states, while other regions favored taffy, licorice, or European chocolates, reflecting regional variations in candy tastes.