NY undefeated Middletown high school football coach resigns after team is kicked out of playoffs
Key Points:
- Tim Strenfel resigned as head coach of Middletown High School football less than a week after his undefeated team was forced to forfeit a playoff win due to using an ineligible player for 53 seconds.
- The ineligible player, a kicker who had previously played soccer, did not meet the minimum three-game regular-season participation requirement for postseason eligibility according to New York State Public High School Athletic Association rules.
- Middletown's 48-15 semifinal victory over Valley Central was forfeited after the opposing coaches noticed the player and reported the violation, leading to a ruling by Section IX officials and an unsuccessful appeal to the State Supreme Court.
- Middletown officials criticized the forfeit as "arbitrary and capricious," attributing the error to adults and expressing disappointment over the impact on student-athletes.
- Valley Central replaced Middletown in the Section IX Class AA Final, defeating Newburgh Free Academy and advancing to face Christian Brothers Academy in the regional championship.