Which NFL rookies thrived in preseason? And who is ready to start?

Key Points:

• Several first-round rookies from the 2026 NFL Draft have made strong preseason impressions, including David Bailey (Jets), Arvell Reese (Giants), and Caleb Downs (Cowboys), who have shown readiness to contribute immediately.
• Some rookies like Jeremiya Love (Cardinals) and Carnell Tate (Titans) are considered ready to start despite minor setbacks or limited preseason stats, indicating potential for significant impact in their rookie seasons.
• A few first-round picks face uncertainties due to injuries or development needs, such as Fernando Mendoza (Raiders), Jordyn Tyson (Saints), and Kenyon Sadiq (Jets), who have shown flashes but require more time or health recovery.
• Offensive linemen like Spencer Fano (Browns), Blake Miller (Lions), and Keylan Rutledge (Texans) have adapted well to the NFL, earning starting roles and contributing positively to their teams' offenses.
• Defensive rookies such as Akheem Mesidor (Chargers) and Keldric Faulk (Titans) have impressed with their physicality and versatility, suggesting they could become key defensive players early in their careers.