Winners, losers of the CNN California gubernatorial debate

Key Points:

• For the third consecutive week, California governor candidates debated in a two-hour CNN-hosted session, marking their first national audience appearance as mail ballots began arriving statewide.
• Columnist Gustavo Arellano highlighted Antonio Villaraigosa's notable improvement, praising his accountability and strong stance on issues like the high-speed rail project, suggesting he may be staging a comeback.
• Mark Z. Barabak observed no major breakthroughs, noting Xavier Becerra's steady rise as the leading candidate following Eric Swalwell's exit, with little indication of a dramatic shift before the election.
• Anita Chabria criticized Republican Chad Bianco for his extremist ties and conspiracy theories, suggesting Steve Hilton may benefit among moderate GOP voters, while noting Katie Porter's clear policy positions but potential voter concerns over her temperament.
• Tom Steyer was recognized for his lively, direct debate style and far-left positioning, appealing to some Democrats frustrated with the status quo, though Becerra maintained a steady, unflappable presence.