2026 NFL Draft Round 1 grades: Arvell Reese pick an A-plus for Giants; Rams get a C
The New York Times • • general
Key Points:
- The Las Vegas Raiders selected QB Fernando Mendoza from Indiana with the first overall pick, earning an A grade for his leadership, arm strength, and potential as a franchise quarterback.
- The New York Jets took edge rusher David Bailey from Texas Tech at No. 2, considered the best pure pass rusher in the draft, but some believe Ohio State's Arvell Reese offered better long-term value; Bailey received an A-minus grade.
- The New York Giants had a strong start, picking edge rusher Arvell Reese at No. 5 and offensive tackle Francis Mauigoa at No. 10, with Reese earning an A-plus for his upside and versatility, and Mauigoa an A for his run-blocking skills.
- The Dallas Cowboys selected safety Caleb Downs from Ohio State at No. 11, praised as the best player in the draft pound-for-pound and a perfect fit for their needs, earning an A-plus grade.
- Some picks raised questions, such as the Miami Dolphins choosing OT Kadyn Proctor (B-minus) due to inconsistency and weight concerns, and the Los Angeles Rams drafting QB Ty Simpson (grade not given) as a backup with uncertain NFL readiness.
