An Emmy Voter Shares Their Brutally Honest Picks and Why

Key Points:

• An anonymous male Emmy-winning TV Academy member shared candid insights on his 2023 Emmy ballot choices, emphasizing personal preferences and critiques rather than representing the entire voting body.
• For Best Drama Series, he voted for HBO Max’s The Pitt, praising its consistent quality in casting, acting, writing, and directing, while criticizing other nominees like The Gilded Age and Slow Horses.
• In Best Comedy Series, Widow’s Bay (Apple TV) was his clear favorite due to its humor, cleverness, and traditional weekly release format, dismissing shows like The Bear and Only Murders in the Building.
• For Best Limited or Anthology Series, he chose The Beast in Me (Netflix), expressing frustration over category nominations and disapproval of shows that disparage real people, such as Winning Time and Love Story.
• Remarkably Bright Creatures (Netflix) was his pick for Best Movie, valuing its small, beautifully told story and strong performances, while criticizing the category's shift away from traditional TV movies and dismissing other nominees.