Biden-era spending law found unconstitutional by federal appeals court
Key Points:
- A federal appeals court ruled 9-8 that the 2022 pandemic-era $1.7 trillion omnibus spending bill was unconstitutional because many lawmakers voted by proxy, which does not count toward a quorum under the US Constitution.
- Proxy voting was allowed due to COVID-19 health risks, but the court majority found no evidence of an emergency justifying this practice, making the bill's passage invalid.
- The ruling specifically blocks enforcement of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas, following a 2023 lawsuit by Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, though the court emphasized the decision’s narrow scope.
- The dissent argued that no quorum objections were raised during the vote and criticized the majority’s strict interpretation of the Constitution’s quorum requirements.
- The 2022 omnibus bill funded critical government operations, emergency aid to Ukraine and NATO, and disaster relief, highlighting potential broader impacts if other proxy-voted laws were challenged.