Bonus 263: Taking Court Reform Unseriously
Key Points:
- University of Chicago law professor Will Baude argues in a New York Times op-ed that the Supreme Court has performed well under pressure during President Trump’s second term, ruling against Trump on key issues and thus deserves praise rather than overhaul.
- Baude contends that reforms motivated by anger at specific rulings risk politicizing the Court further, and that any true flaws should be addressed by the justices themselves improving their conduct, with modest reforms aimed mainly at restoring public confidence.
- The newsletter author agrees with Baude’s caution against damaging reforms but criticizes Baude for failing to acknowledge specific institutional problems, arguing that the Court’s main issue is its hubris and lack of accountability, especially among the six Republican-appointed justices.
- The author asserts that urging justices to “try harder” ignores evidence that many justices do not feel compelled to do so, highlighting a deeper problem than just the Court’s public image.
- Regular Court coverage will resume in the newsletter on Monday, with additional content available for paid subscribers.