Generated Text Is In Today's Philosophy Journals? (guest post)
AI Image

Generated Text Is In Today's Philosophy Journals? (guest post)

Daily Nous • • health

Key Points:

  • A recent investigation by Maximillian Noichl estimates that about 12% of philosophy papers published in 2026 involve some AI assistance, with the figure varying based on detection methods and thresholds.
  • The study used the open-source AI detection tool MELD, which analyzes text token by token to identify AI-generated or AI-assisted content, calibrated against papers from pre-AI years to control false positives.
  • Analysis of multiple philosophy sources, including journals Philosophers’ Imprint and Ergo, as well as preprint archives like PhilSci-Archive and PhilPapers, showed increasing AI use, especially in preprints where AI-generated content can reach up to 62%.
  • Most AI use detected is partial, involving localized editing or assistance rather than fully AI-generated papers, though some largely AI-generated papers have been published; preprint servers are particularly affected by high volumes of AI-generated texts.
  • The study highlights the need for open discussion on acceptable AI use in philosophy and suggests that automated AI detection may soon be necessary for preprint moderation, while noting limitations and potential false positives in current detection methods.

Trending Business

Trending Technology

Trending Health