Hawaii Supreme Court declares Council Chair Tommy Waters ineligible for election
Key Points:
- The Hawaii Supreme Court ruled 3-2 that Council Chair Tommy Waters is ineligible to run for another term due to serving nearly eight years, upholding a lower court decision.
- The legal battle began after Waters' candidacy was approved despite a two-term limit in the county charter; Waters argued his first term started late and did not count as a full term.
- The majority justices disagreed, affirming that Waters served a full term regardless of the delayed start, while two dissenting justices would have allowed him to stay in the race.
- Waters was disqualified after votes were already cast, but still finished second in the primary; the court ordered the top two eligible candidates, Trevor Ozawa and Tara Gregory, to proceed to the general election runoff.
- A group of 40 voters challenged Waters' disqualification, claiming disenfranchisement, and Waters has a separate formal appeal pending based on similar facts.