ICE offers contractor operating deportation flights windfall and secrecy, data shows
Key Points:
- ICE has agreed to pay CSI Aviation up to $305.7 million without competitive bidding and modified a contract to use the FAA's LADD program, which hides ICE aircraft from public flight-tracking websites, raising concerns about transparency in deportation flights.
- In October, ICE signed a new $1.28 billion contract with CSI to continue charter flights for another year, including outsourcing the task of compiling passenger lists for deportation flights, a responsibility traditionally held by ICE staff.
- Critics, including human rights advocates and Democratic lawmakers, argue that hiding flight information undermines oversight, accountability, and the rule of law, while ICE claims the staffing deal is necessary due to increased operational demands and limited agency resources.
- The use of LADD to block flight tracking has significantly hindered public monitoring of ICE flights, complicating efforts by nonprofits and advocates to track deportations, despite alternative tracking methods still existing but requiring more labor-intensive efforts.
- The contract awards to CSI have faced legal challenges and protests over procurement processes, with ongoing concerns about the revolving door between ICE and contractors, and CSI’s involvement in controversial deportation operations, including a current lawsuit alleging complicity in unlawful transfers.