Ron Johnson’s Social Security plan would add $190 trillion to the national debt, CRFB says
Key Points:
- Wisconsin Republican Senator Ron Johnson proposed the Stop Scaring Seniors Act, which would allow the Treasury Secretary to fund Social Security benefits from the general fund once the retirement trust fund is depleted, avoiding benefit cuts but adding an estimated $190 trillion to the national debt over 75 years.
- The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB) warns that passing the bill could alarm bond markets, potentially triggering financial turmoil by increasing borrowing costs, with projections showing a rise in Treasury yields and mortgage rates if Social Security is funded through general revenue.
- Currently, Social Security benefits are paid from payroll taxes and the trust fund, which legally limits payouts; Johnson's plan removes this limit, effectively treating Social Security like any other government program funded by borrowing.
- Johnson argues that Americans have been misled about Social Security funding, calling it a "legal Ponzi scheme" and advocating for addressing the overall federal deficit rather than isolating Social Security, though CRFB suggests a bipartisan solution to fix the program without ballooning debt.
- The bill revives Johnson’s long-standing criticism of political tactics that "scare seniors" about Social Security cuts, and comes amid concerns over the approaching debt ceiling, which could constrain government borrowing before the Social Security trust fund is exhausted.