SI’s 2026 NFL Preseason QB Rankings: Reigning MVP Matthew Stafford Is No. 3

Key Points:

• The 2026 NFL quarterback landscape remains largely unchanged, with only a few new starters like Malik Willis, Fernando Mendoza, Geno Smith, and Kyler Murray among the teams. The top quarterback debate centers on Patrick Mahomes and Josh Allen, with Mahomes holding a slight edge despite recovering from an ACL injury.
• At the lower end of the rankings, rookies and younger quarterbacks such as Shedeur Sanders, Jacoby Brissett, Bryce Young, and Fernando Mendoza face challenges due to inexperience, team instability, or lack of offensive weapons.
• Established quarterbacks like Sam Darnold, Jared Goff, and Daniel Jones show varying degrees of consistency and potential, while others like Aaron Rodgers and Baker Mayfield are seen as having limited upside or facing critical contract years.
• Promising talents such as Caleb Williams, Trevor Lawrence, and Joe Burrow are poised for potential breakout or comeback seasons, with Burrow's health being pivotal for the Cincinnati Bengals' success.
• Patrick Mahomes leads the quarterback rankings due to his multiple championships, MVP awards, and overall achievements, but faces pressure to maintain dominance amid rising competition, particularly from Josh Allen and other emerging stars.