‘Smart’ implants drive up costs even when patients don’t ask for them
Key Points:
- Steve Russak received a "smart knee" implant called Persona IQ, equipped with sensors and a transmitter to send data about his movement to clinicians and the manufacturer Zimmer Biomet, without his informed consent or clear explanation.
- Russak is suing Zimmer Biomet, his doctor, and Canary Medical for unauthorized implantation and lack of informed consent, citing privacy concerns and practical issues such as MRI incompatibility; Zimmer and Canary deny all allegations.
- Smart medical devices like the Persona IQ are part of a growing trend in healthcare, offering remote patient monitoring that may improve care but also raise privacy risks, lack strong evidence of clinical benefit, and increase healthcare costs.
- Medicare and private insurers reimburse providers for monitoring data from such devices, with payments for remote patient monitoring doubling in recent years, though government watchdogs warn of fraud risks and inappropriate patient enrollment.
- Experts express ambivalence about the clinical value of smart knees, describing them as "nice-to-have" rather than essential, and highlight the need for more rigorous data on their effectiveness and stronger consent standards due to ongoing data collection embedded in patients’ bodies.