The Not-So-Special Relationship

Key Points:

• In 2023, Tablet magazine writers Jacob Siegel and Liel Leibovitz, both supporters of Israel, argued for ending U.S. aid to Israel, claiming it harms Israel by imposing political constraints and limiting its defense autonomy.
• Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has recently supported the idea of phasing out U.S. military aid, reflecting a growing trend within Israel questioning the benefits of American assistance.
• U.S.-Israel relations have deteriorated politically despite strong military ties, with public opinion in the U.S. turning more critical of Israel and bipartisan political support weakening.
• Siegel contends that the distancing between the U.S. and Israel is inevitable and potentially beneficial, offering Israel opportunities for greater independence and growth despite the challenges.
• The article challenges the notion that restoring traditional U.S.-Israel ties depends on political changes in America, urging supporters to acknowledge shifting geopolitical realities rather than seek an American "savior."