2026 NFL rookie grades: How every first-round pick performed in preseason

Key Points:

• First-round NFL rookies showed varied preseason performances, with some like RB Jeremiyah Love (A-) and EDGE David Bailey (B+) impressing through skillful play and physicality, while others like WR Carnell Tate (C) and OT Blake Miller (D+) faced challenges in execution and consistency.
• Quarterbacks Fernando Mendoza (C+) and Ty Simpson (B) demonstrated potential but also areas needing improvement; Mendoza struggled under pressure partly due to unfamiliarity with under-center snaps, and Simpson showed accuracy and quick decision-making with a simplified game plan.
• Injuries impacted availability and preseason reps for several rookies, including WR Jordyn Tyson and TE Kenyon Sadiq, both sidelined and unable to participate, while RB Jeremiyah Love sustained an ankle injury but is expected to be ready for Week 1.
• Positional versatility was noted in players like Francis Mauigoa, transitioning from tackle to guard with strong run-blocking ability, and Monroe Freeling, successfully switching tackle sides, indicating adaptability amid team needs.
• Teams are managing rookies' development carefully, balancing preseason exposure with injury risks, as seen with limited snaps for players like Caleb Downs and Rueben Bain Jr., and cautious integration plans for others like Jadarian Price, who missed the entire preseason due to soreness.